The Impact of Poor Data Governance on Business Performance

Data AnalyticsData SciencePrivacy

Effective data governance frameworks help organisations manage data by ensuring accuracy, consistency, and protection. Businesses can enhance their data quality and support strategic decision-making by implementing clear policies and standards. Let’s explore data governance and why it’s essential for your organisation.

What is Data Governance?

Data governance is the framework that ensures data is accurate, accessible, consistent, and protected. It involves setting policies and standards to manage data across an organisation.

There typically four primary components to a data governance framework:

  • Data quality: Ensuring data is accurate, complete, and reliable.

  • Data management: Processes for acquiring, storing, and maintaining data.

  • Data policies: Rules and guidelines for data use and handling.

  • Data stewardship: Assigning responsibilities for data management and oversight.

Data governance ensures compliance with regulations, protects sensitive information, and enhances operational efficiency. Good data governance supports strategic goals and boosts competitive advantage.

The Importance of Data Governance

Governance ensures teams manage data effectively, providing a solid data foundation for reliable and strategic operations.

Ensuring data accuracy and reliability

Accurate and reliable data is the backbone of any organisation, ensuring quality by implementing strict standards and regular audits. This framework reduces errors and inconsistencies, leading to more reliable information for decision-making.

Enhancing decision-making processes

Accurate, well-managed data empowers leaders to make informed decisions quickly, resulting in better strategies and more effective operations.

Compliance with regulations and standards

Regulations like GDPR and CCPA mandate strict data handling practices. Data governance helps businesses comply with these laws, avoiding fines and legal issues while meeting industry standards.

Protecting sensitive information and data privacy

Data governance protects sensitive information from breaches and misuse by establishing strong privacy policies and security measures. Companies publish these policies to build trust with employees and customers and maintain a positive brand reputation.

Gaining a competitive edge

Effective data governance allows businesses to collect and utilise valuable first-party data. This data provides unique insights into customer behaviour and market trends, giving companies a competitive edge. Reliable data also enhances marketing strategies and operational efficiency.

Consequences of Poor Data Governance

Poor data governance can have far-reaching and damaging effects on an organisation. It results in operational inefficiencies, financial losses, reputational damage, increased risk of data breaches, and compliance violations.

Inaccurate data leads to flawed decision-making, while inefficient data management hampers productivity. Data breaches and misuse erode customer trust and loyalty, further impacting business performance.

Operational inefficiencies

Poor data governance leads to operational inefficiencies, resulting in flawed decision-making and causing projects to veer off course. Inaccurate, redundant, and incorrect data increase operational costs, as employees waste time correcting errors and searching for reliable information.

According to Metaplane, companies dealing with poor data quality often face customer dissatisfaction and operational inefficiencies due to the mishandling of data across various systems​. These poor data quality issues cause significant delays and increase operational costs.

Financial impact

Poor data governance can lead to lost revenue from missed opportunities and incur high costs due to data breaches and non-compliance fines.

A case study from Data Governance: The Definitive Guidedescribes a company that faced substantial fines due to non-compliance with data protection regulations. This financial burden and the loss of business from eroded customer trust underscored the critical need for effective data governance​.

Reputational damage

Poor data governance results in reputational damage, leading to a loss of customer trust and loyalty, adversely impacting a brand’s image.

In a 2022 article, NetApp details how a multinational security company exposed data by misconfiguring its storage. The embarrassing incident resulted in widespread negative media coverage and a significant loss of customer confidence, demonstrating the far-reaching impacts of poor data governance.

Increased risk of data security breaches

Inadequate data governance increases the risk of data security breaches. Weak data protection measures make organisations vulnerable to cyberattacks and data leaks.

Returning to the NetApp article above, a misconfigured Amazon S3 bucket allowed unauthorised access to nearly 3 TB of data, highlighting the critical need for robust data governance to prevent such vulnerabilities​.

Compliance violations

Poor data governance often leads to compliance violations as companies fail to adhere to regulations like GDPR and HIPAA, resulting in hefty fines and legal actions.

Data Governance: The Definitive Guide details how a company’s non-compliance with data protection laws led to significant financial penalties and damaged its market credibility. Companies can prevent violations, fines, and reputation damage by incorporating compliance into data governance frameworks.

Inaccurate decision-making​

Poor data governance directly impacts decision-making. When decision-makers use unreliable information, companies make flawed strategic decisions, adversely affecting business performance.

The popular real estate marketplace, Zillow learnt an expensive lesson in poor decision-making due to flawed data. The company lost over $300 million when decision-makers relied on a machine-learning algorithm powered by poor data to implement strategies and decisions. This issue, stemming from poor data governance, led to significant financial losses and underscored the importance of accurate data for decision-making.

Lost productivity and efficiency

Ineffective data governance often results in time-wasting exercises as employees search for reliable information. Teams must find solutions to errors or create undesirable “workarounds” hampering productivity.

Data Ladder illustrates how data quality issues lead to operational paralysis. Employees spent considerable time correcting data errors, which reduced overall productivity and efficiency​​. This situation demonstrates the need for streamlined data governance processes to reduce unnecessary tasks and enhance productivity.

Erosion of customer trust

Data breaches and misuse lead to a loss of customer loyalty and confidence. A perfect example is the 2018 British Airways data breach, which compromised the personal and financial information of nearly 500,000 customers.

The breach resulted in significant reputational damage, as their customer satisfaction and reputation scores plummeted, illustrating the long-term impact of losing customer trust due to poor data governance.​

Signs of Poor Data Governance

Recognising poor data governance is crucial to maintaining effective data management and safeguarding business performance. Here are key indicators to watch for.

Data inconsistencies

Data inconsistencies occur when there are duplicate or conflicting records within the database, resulting in confusion and errors in decision-making.

What to look for:

  • Duplicate entries in databases.

  • Conflicting information across different systems.

  • Frequent errors in data reports.

  • Inconsistent data formats.

Lack of data ownership

When responsibilities for data management are unclear, it results in a lack of accountability, resulting in inconsistent data quality and mismanagement.

What to look for:

  • No designated data stewards or owners.

  • Confusion about who is responsible for data updates.

  • Lack of clear data governance policies.

  • Data issues not being addressed promptly.

Poor data quality

Poor data quality involves inaccurate, incomplete, or outdated data, impacting the reliability of business insights and decisions.

What to look for:

  • High volumes of missing or incomplete data fields.

  • Outdated information that is not regularly updated.

  • Frequent errors in data analysis reports.

  • Data that doesn’t meet business requirements.

Regulatory non-compliance

Failing to meet industry standards and legal requirements for data management can lead to significant fines and reputational damage.

What to look for:

  • Lack of adherence to GDPR, HIPAA, or other relevant regulations.

  • Missing documentation for data handling practices.

  • Frequent audit failures.

  • Legal notices or fines related to data practices.

Inefficient data processes

Inefficient data processes involve slow and cumbersome data retrieval and processing, which hampers productivity.

What to look for:

  • Long wait times to retrieve or process data.

  • Complex and non-intuitive data systems.

  • Frequent bottlenecks in data workflows.

  • High manual effort required for data handling.

Strategies to Improve Data Governance

Establish clear data policies

Developing and implementing comprehensive data governance policies is essential for ensuring consistency and reliability in data management. These policies should define how your teams collect, store, process, and share data.

Start by identifying critical data assets and the rules governing their use. Engage stakeholders from various departments to ensure policies are relevant and practical.

For example, a healthcare provider might implement a policy requiring regular patient record updates to maintain accuracy. This policy would detail the data entry, verification, and correction processes. These clear guidelines help maintain high data quality and ensure compliance with health regulations like HIPAA.

Assign data stewards

Data stewards are individuals responsible for specific data domains. These stewards ensure that data is accurate, accessible, and used appropriately. Their responsibilities include data validation, quality control, and compliance with governance policies.

For example, a financial institution might assign a data steward to oversee customer account data. This steward ensures that all entries are correct and up-to-date, reducing errors in financial reporting and enhancing customer trust. Organisations can maintain high data quality and governance standards by having dedicated data stewards.

Invest in data management tools

Investing in robust data management tools can significantly enhance data governance practices. These tools offer capabilities like data profiling, cleansing, and monitoring. They help identify data quality issues and ensure compliance with governance policies.

For example, a retail company might use a cloud management data tool like Informatica to integrate customer data from various sources. The tool can identify duplicates and inconsistencies, ensuring customer information is accurate and reliable. By leveraging technology, businesses can streamline their data management processes and improve overall data quality.

Regular audits and assessments

Regular data audits and assessments help identify areas of improvement and ensure that teams follow data governance policies correctly. Schedule periodic audits and use the findings to refine your data governance strategies.

For example, a global manufacturing firm might conduct quarterly data audits to ensure that inventory data is accurate and up-to-date. These audits can reveal discrepancies or outdated records, allowing the company to address issues promptly. Regular assessments ensure that data governance practices remain effective and relevant.

Training and awareness

Educating employees on the importance of data governance and their roles in maintaining data quality ensures staff understand data governance policies and best practices. We also recommend encouraging a culture of data stewardship and ownership across the organisation.

For example, a tech company might hold monthly data security and privacy workshops. These sessions cover topics like recognising phishing attempts and handling sensitive data. By fostering awareness and understanding, organisations can ensure that employees are proactive in maintaining data integrity.

Implementing a data governance framework

Establishing data governance frameworks like DAMA-DMBOK or CMMI provides a structured approach to managing data. These frameworks offer best practices and guidelines for data governance, helping organisations standardise their processes.

For example, a multinational corporation might adopt the DAMA-DMBOK framework to structure its data governance strategy. This framework helps the company define roles, responsibilities, and processes for data management. Using a recognised framework ensures that data governance practices are comprehensive and aligned with industry standards.

Change management

Implementing and sustaining data governance initiatives requires effective change management, including stakeholder engagement, communication strategies, and training programmes. Monitor the progress of data governance initiatives and adjust strategies as needed.

For example, a pharmaceutical company implementing a new data governance policy might involve all departments in the planning phase to ensure buy-in. Regular updates and feedback sessions can help address concerns and ensure smooth implementation. Effective change management ensures that the organisation adopts and maintains data governance practices.

How to Implement a Data Governance Framework

Following these steps ensures a comprehensive and effective implementation of a data governance framework, improving overall data management practices and aligning with strategic goals.

Step 1: Define objectives and scope

Set clear goals for your data governance initiative. Identify whether you aim to improve data quality, ensure compliance, or enhance decision-making. Clearly define the scope, including the data domains and business areas. This scope and objectives help align the data governance efforts with your organisation’s strategic goals.

Step 2: Establish a governance structure

Form a governance team comprising data stewards, custodians, and various departments’ data managers. Assign clear roles and responsibilities to ensure accountability. A well-defined structure ensures everyone understands their part in maintaining data integrity and compliance.

Step 3: Adopt a data governance framework

Choose and implement a recognised data governance framework to fit your organisation’s needs and context. This framework provides a structured approach and ensures your data governance practices are comprehensive and standardised.

Step 4: Develop data policies and standards

Create comprehensive data governance policies that outline data management practices, data quality standards, and compliance requirements. Standardise data definitions across the organisation to ensure consistency and clarity. These standards help maintain high data quality and ensure regulatory compliance.

Step 5: Assign data stewards

Appoint data stewards responsible for specific data domains. Clearly define their responsibilities for maintaining data accuracy, accessibility, and quality. Data stewards play a crucial role in ensuring data integrity and adherence to governance policies.

Step 6: Invest in data management tools

Select data management tools to facilitate data integration, visualisation, quality control, and monitoring. Integrate these tools with your existing IT infrastructure to help streamline data management processes and enhance data quality.

Step 7: Provide training and raise awareness

Conduct regular training sessions to educate employees about data governance policies and their roles in maintaining data quality. Promote a culture of data stewardship to ensure employees understand the importance of high-quality data so everyone follows best practices.

Step 8: Conduct regular audits and assessments

Schedule regular data audits to review quality and compliance with governance policies. Use audit findings to assess the effectiveness of your data governance framework and make necessary adjustments. Regular assessments help maintain high standards and address issues promptly.

Step 9: Implement change management

Engage stakeholders in the planning and implementation phases to ensure buy-in and support. Communicate changes clearly and regularly to all stakeholders. Effective change management ensures smooth implementation and sustainability of data governance initiatives.

Step 10: Monitor and adjust

Regularly review and refine the data governance framework based on feedback and evolving business needs. Track key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure the success of your data governance initiatives. Continuous monitoring and adjustment ensure the framework remains effective and aligned with organisational goals.

Streamline data governance with Metric Labs

Implementing a robust data governance framework ensures data accuracy, compliance, and efficiency, but these tasks can feel complex and overwhelming without expert data analytics expertise. Our data analytics experts have helped countless businesses at all maturity levels implement and improve data governance—from initial audit, implementation and management to continuous monitoring and refining.

Contact Metric Labs for a free discovery call and discover how we can streamline your data governance with purpose-built strategies that align with your business goals.


Like this blog post?

Sign up to our email newsletter – Lab Report – and never miss a new one!

Upskill your team with Google Analytics 4 Training!